• If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • Social distancing? Try a better way to work remotely on your online files. Dokkio, a new product from PBworks, can help your team find, organize, and collaborate on your Drive, Gmail, Dropbox, Box, and Slack files. Sign up for free.


HHMI Assessment Mathematical Competence

Page history last edited by erickuo 6 years, 9 months ago

Data Collection Main Page


Assessing Mathematical Competence

see also Quantitative Skills and Reasoning on Assessing Competencies page


What is mathematical competence (in this course)?

Below is a tentative list of things we might mean. First order of business it to see what we already do and how it maps to or helps us expand/modify a list like this.


Making sense of equations

  •  mapping between the symbols and the world
  •  attending to dimensions and units


Building mathematical models

  • creating equations that describe natural/physical situations
  • understanding assumptions/limitations
  • choosing appropriate parameters/units


Manipulating equations and interpreting solutions

  • rearranging equations to gain insight
  • interpreting solutions
  • exploring sensitivities and limits


Working with and coordinating multiple mathematical representations

  • coordinating among different representations
  • understanding, interpreting and choosing among representational forms


Quantification and Estimation

  • knowing when quantification can yield insights
  • appropriate use of estimation


More Data in:

PHYS 131:132 HW - Math Competencies.xlsx


What competencies are students most asked to show in Phys 131/132 (fall 2012 - spring 2013)?


  • Generating equations from canonical ideas in physics that describe specific natural/physical situations:
    (Problems where the answer can't be found by directly applying a known equation.  A conceptual understanding of the situation is needed to figure out how to manipulate or generate equations.)
    • The Cat and the Antelope
    • The Tortoise and the Hare
    • Testing the motion detector
    • Diffusion and Slime Molds
    • What if the Greenland Ice Sheet Melts?
    • Fish Buoyancy
    • Polymers and Entropy
    • Free Expansion
  •  Connecting graphs to physical situations/concepts
    • Graph for a cart on a tilted airtrack - with spring
    • Hitting a Bowling Ball
    • Carts and Graphs
    • Bound States
    • Going to a Deeper Well
    • The Train, the hill, and the bumper
    • Thermal to Chemical Energy Transfer
    • The Penny and the Jelly Donut
    • The Bulldog on the skateboard
    • Tracking Round a Circuit
    • SHO Energies
  • Numerical Estimation in Scientific Contexts
    • Sensing Molecular Signals
    • How big is a protein molecule?
    • Moving through a Cell
    • Blood and Breath
    • Propelling a Paramecium
    • What if the Greenland Ice Sheet Melts?
    • Muscle Contraction
    • The Penny and the Jelly Donut
    • Population Growth: I
    • Counting Charges
    • Packing DNA
    • Atorvastatin Calcium
    • Interfering Atoms 
  • Dimensional Analysis (2 categories: either "attending to dimensions" in making sense of equations or "choosing appropriate dimensions" in building mathematical models)
    • Counting Cubes
    • Propelling a Paramecium
    • Diffusion and Viscosity
    • Enthalpy calculation for a simple molecule
    • Boltzmann -- chemist or physicist?
    • Capacitance dimensions
  • Investigating dependencies with equations (2 categories: either "using equations to investigate dependencies/proportionality" or "exploring sensitivities and limits" in manipulation equations and interpreting solutions)
    • Heat Generation Big and Small
    • The Cat and the Antelope
    • Forces between charges
    • Analyzing Dipoles
    • Random vs Coherent Motion
    • Polymers and Entropy
    • Random or not, here I come
    • Free Expansion
    • Both Ions Moving 




Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.